It’s Time for Steam to Update Family Sharing

steamI love Steam’s Family Sharing feature. I’m always a little peeved when I take a step back and notice the fast-paced tech industry ignoring the concept of “family unit” in favor of pushing everything towards individuals with credit cards. This is especially irritating in the gaming world, when you realize that historically, video games were developed and marketed mainly towards kids, and without whom the industry itself might not even exist, today. So I’m always happy to see big companies like Apple, Amazon and Valve taking families into consideration through sharing and parental features.

Back in the “old days”, a personal computer was not seen as the necessity it is today. At best, most families saw it as a glorified mash-up between a typewriter and a calculator. Something that was helpful, but certainly not a necessity. The price tag (in the thousands of dollars) also prohibited the notion of multiple PC’s per household. It simply wasn’t worth the expenditure considering that most of the things that you could do on a PC could also be done manually, albeit slower. The one exception to this may have been gaming. While some early PC games could be somewhat replicated offline (text-based MUDs, point & click story games, card games), some of the more action-oriented games could only be otherwise played at an actual arcade. The notion of blasting asteroids or munching power pellets in the comfort of your own surroundings was new, and heartily embraced by those who had time to spend learning this new craft: kids.

Apple IIc

Recall that no households (apart from Silicon Valley CEO’s, perhaps) owned more than a single PC. This meant that a game purchased for a household was installed on the computer and shared between anybody who happened to be using that machine. The game wouldn’t run only for a single user of that PC. How ludicrous! Each and every person who had physical access to the machine also had access to the game. And do you know what? Game companies survived. Even without expecting a family to pay money for each individual kid within a household to play their game, they somehow still thrive today. (Side note: if you did happen to have multiple computers, a single game purchase could be easily installed on each of them. Prior to license keys being a thing, all you really needed for multiple installs was the physical media.)

This is the concept that Steam family sharing mimics with its implementation. The biggest difference between “the good old days” and today is the proliferation of multiple gaming devices within a household. While the “new world” model of selling a software license to an individual user account is good for some things, like recovery or movement of games between devices, it’s very non-family friendly and actually encourages a behavior that is particularly insecure (and, in fact, specifically strongly discouraged via Steam’s anti-phishing recommendations): account password sharing. The only way for kids to play a game purchased by a parent through Steam originally was to share the same account credentials between all family members. Anybody raised in the information age knows that sharing credentials of any kind can lead to really bad results – especially if one of your kids decides to also share those details with his/her friends!

The current family sharing feature was launched in early 2014, and allows account holders to share steam game libraries after a somewhat clunky initial setup. The setup steps require each sharer to physically log into their steam account on every physical computer that the library is intended to be shared on. Further, the sharer must give permission for each user account to be shared with on that physical computer. One stipulation to family sharing is that a “shared” game can only be played by one user account at a time. This makes sense to me from a licensing standpoint, and it also mimics the ‘old days’ of having a single shared game installed on a single computer at a time.

Nearly two years in, I have only one wish for family sharing. While they’ve done a nice job mimicking the sharing policies of old, I believe that it’s possible for Valve to take it a step further and actually improve video game sharing between family members by instituting some simple parental controls. At present when a library is shared with a child, the “sharer” has no control over which games the “share-ee” can download or stream. The entire library is an all-or-nothing proposition. To be completely honest, there are some games in my library that I don’t feel a responsible parent should be sharing with his/her children below a certain age. My library, which contains Plants vs. Zombies and Lego Star Wars, also has several “M” rated games for certain elements that I’d prefer not to just hand over to my pre-teens. A simple solution would be to allow the “sharer” of the library to selectively share games with specific steam accounts. Or use a “share by rating” option that would allow you to exclude all games over a certain rating. Alternatively, it could at least notify you if a certain Steam account has installed or started to stream one of your games. With the current setup, I’m never notified if someone has installed a shared game. I’ve learned after the fact (twice) that one of my kids has installed or started to install what I would consider an inappropriate game only after walking past and observing said game being played/installed. I’d prefer a little proactive parenting to having to react to something that’s already happened without my knowledge.

Kid Gaming

It’s been almost two years since Steam rolled out family sharing, and there doesn’t appear to be a plan to change its current function. In the tech world, two years without an update is a pretty long time. C’mon Steam, be the industry leader and innovator that we still picture you as! I think it’s time that you stepped up and help parents out a little. After all, the games industry is what it is today thanks to the kids of yesteryear. Let’s help out those same kids as they venture into the gauntlet of parenthood.

*Update: since completing this post, I’ve done some additional research into family sharing. It seems that there are other glaring issues with this feature that I’ve never personally noticed but have been present since initial launch and have gone unanswered/ignored by Valve. For example, “sharing” is done on a per-library level, so two kids cannot play different games out of my library simultaneously. This is certainly an unexpected limitation, and something that should have been corrected within the last 2 years. I question whether it’s even working as intended, as all of the press I remember reading prior to feature launch said that the same game could not be played by multiple accounts simultaneously. I guess family sharing is not as useful as I once thought.

I’m beginning to wonder if this was one of those “pet projects” that gets launched and quickly abandoned after the developer responsible is promoted. It certainly diminishes my confidence in Steam, and makes me less assured about the large number of games in my library. When can we all go back to physical media, again?


all setup for daily use – the 23 year old Apple //c  by Blake Patterson on Flickr Creative Commons 

Juegos tradicionales by Bea Represa on Flickr Creative Commons 

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “It’s Time for Steam to Update Family Sharing

  1. Braag January 8, 2016 / 9:17 am

    I have a big beef about this too and frequently experience an issue where my child logging into Steam on our Family computer will log me out of my session on my laptop. I am not sure if this issue is unique to me and the way I have set-up Family Sharing or not, but agree with you that it seems to be an inconveniently elaborate process.
    The only way I have found around that “feature” is to initiate the game I am playing OUTSIDE of steam completely. (For example, I have a desktop shortcut for LOTRO for that purpose, but I had to know where the right startup .exe for that game was stored in order to create that. Not very user friendly.
    What If I want to play a game co-op with my child that I purchased through Steam? Which would seem to be a very common use case. Very disappointing.

    Great Article Brax. Thanks for sharing.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Braxwolf January 8, 2016 / 10:20 am

      Thanks, and thanks for the follow!

      Like

  2. bp911 September 10, 2016 / 8:46 pm

    I’ve wondered how to get around some of these issues without upsetting the pocket books of the developers. I often want to buy a coop game for my wife and I to play but the reality is I will play it for 10-20 hours for every hour she plays so buying multiple 60$ copies usually doesn’t make much sense. Some indie games will come with multiple keys and that’s a great perk but it opens them up to friends “splitting” the costs, something Penny pinching mega corps like EA are not likely to ever do.

    One of my thoughts was to bring back the original coop, LAN. Offer a the product (or a version of the product) with a LAN only key that allows you to play coop with other devices in the house but won’t allow coop with random internet players. That satisfies the players like me who want to be able to play coop with immediate family or friends who drop by and play on my spare PC without forcing me to buy multiple copies (which doesn’t happen so in reality their just loosing a sale completely). It would also allow scenarios like my second one where the game is more tied to the PC then to an individual account, allowing me to have a second/third “loaner” PC for visitors to use to play along with us. For now I work around those issues with a second steam account for games I might play with visitors (like torchlight 2 or some party style indie games).

    Liked by 1 person

    • Braxwolf September 21, 2016 / 10:32 pm

      I have somewhat mixed feelings. On one hand, I want it to be like it used to be so I can share my (disk/cartridge) with my friends and family. On the other hand, with the way games are priced now I can see why they’d want to sell individual licenses to each player.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s