The War on Terrible

I’m not going to do a “Gamergate” post. I haven’t followed it closely enough to have much of a thought process on the subject, and what I do know doesn’t interest me enough to provoke any further research. What does concern me a bit, however, is how much these circumstances, the implications, and the responses has disturbed the people with whom I feel a strong affinity. I hate to see my friends in agony over the actions of the ignorant.

The thing that does strike me about the whole situation is the complete contrast between the perception of the gaming community within the circles I run in and the ugliness being spewed over social and conventional media. My friends tend to think of gamers as friendly, inclusive, progressive, and thoughtful, and for the most part I would agree with that assessment. Of course, the risk of being inclusive is that you have to include those who you don’t agree with, those who are not to your taste, and even those who are not inclusive!

While I don’t want to disrespect the heroics of the actual soldiers who keep my country free from tyranny with an ill-advised comparison, I can’t help but recall the US’s “war on terror” brought about by the September 11 atrocities in 2001. The US has always prided itself on being a refuge for all, including the “tired, the poor, the huddled masses yearning to breathe free”. Yet the attacks on our homeland had even the most even-headed among us wondering if perhaps we hadn’t been too inclusive in that list. Had we foolishly thrown open our gates to every nut job with a bomb-vest and an axe to grind?  It’s so tempting to have the knee-jerk reaction. We need more intelligence. We need more guards at the border. We need more security at the airport. Lock it down. We need to do something.

Over at Herding Cats, my friend Liore wonders if she can even continue to express her true feelings about the industry for fear of being lumped in with the radicals:

Now, I don’t know how I can continue being a moderate voice, even if it’s just to my friends. How can I talk about how I think game journalism is flawed when the idea has been inexorably linked to people who will literally ruin someone’s life over it? How can I opine that some games journalists, some of whom happen to be women, are not terribly interesting when that same idea has been wielded like a weapon against people’s safety and livelihoods?

During the war on terror, it was also very difficult to maintain a moderate voice in the immediate wake of the attacks. The “patriot act” was universally supported by politicians on both sides of the aisle, passing the US House of Representatives 357-66, and then the US Senate 98-1. In hindsight, most moderate Americans would probably admit that this particular piece of legislation should have been debated more aggressively and perhaps not even passed at all, considering the compromises to our freedoms that it included. But in the clouded state of affairs and with the feeling that we needed to do something, the act passed and the rest is history.

Patriot Act

To those who are feeling overwhelmed by the current state of affairs, I would say hold tight. Cooler heads will prevail. To those who feel pressured into silence or into a more radical position in order to “balance the scales”, I’d say don’t change! Time will prove your position. Don’t become less inclusive, less friendly, less progressive, less thoughtful. To let the circumstances change you is to let the “terrorists” win. To do otherwise is to truly prove the radicals wrong.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “The War on Terrible

  1. Pasduil September 8, 2014 / 11:22 am

    I haven’t followed GamerGate closely either.

    It’s all a pretty strange world to me, because I have personally come across very little harassment or bigotry in my gaming travels. And I’ve spent a lot of my grouping time running with females who are playing female avatars and black people who are playing black avatars, so if it was happening a lot I’d have expected to see it.

    Personal experience isn’t definitive for the reasons I explained in my “Gamer Label” post, but I do think it’s badly mistaken to view gamers as if being sexist, racist and homophobic was the norm for them.

    I’d compare it to YouTube commenters. There are a lot of idiotic, nasty and childish comments to be found on YouTube, but do they reflect something about YouTube *visitors* as a whole? Prob not, because basically everyone nowadays watches YouTube, but most people most of the time don’t feel the need to comment on anything. Those who do feel the urge are a very unrepresentative sample.

    Like

  2. Looking for Playtime (@L4playtime) September 8, 2014 / 12:28 pm

    Welcome to the modern Leftist movement where the activists seem to believe that the very sources of power and wealth that hold them down are their saviors because talking heads seem to agree with them.

    And we forget that “women as a demographic” came to prominence because they are the most objectified political swing group. They won the 2012 election in the States and this is a trend that is continuing throughout democratic nations in NA and Europe. Let us not forget that this is a demographic that is being fought over with ferver since it is so powerful in terms of determining national politics in the US.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s